Fiona Avdiu
student
University of Prishtina
Kosovo
Urban Design and Landscape
The 'Vertical Fusion: Symbiotic Strategies for Expanding Cities' project explores the concept of Symbiotic Architecture as an innovative approach for the… more
Omar Harb
advisor
Phoenicia University
Lebanon
As an architect and founder of Omar Harb Architects & Associates, my work centers on creating… more
Feedback: Vertical Fusion: Symbiotic Strategies for Expanding Cities
This project, "Vertical Fusion: Symbiotic Strategies for Expanding Cities," presents a compelling and highly relevant solution to address contemporary urban challenges. Fiona, you've developed a sophisticated concept that integrates architectural innovation with pressing societal needs, particularly for expanding cities like Prishtina.
The project idea is exceptionally strong, leveraging the concept of Symbiotic Architecture for vertical expansion. Your identification of key design principles—symbiosis, sustainability, modularity, flexibility, and adaptability—provides a clear and robust framework. Drawing inspiration from visionary architects like Le Corbusier, Renzo Piano, and Cedric Price further positions your work within a tradition of forward-thinking design. The aim to improve quality of life and contribute to sustainable urban development, with a replicable model, highlights the project's ambition and potential impact.
The project description outlines a rigorous four-phase methodology, starting with a comprehensive urban context study and progressing to a pilot neighborhood analysis (Bregu i Diellit) and specific building cluster selection before developing the conceptual proposal. The detailed research approach, including satellite mapping, demographic analysis, urban regulation review, fieldwork, community questionnaires, and case studies, demonstrates a thorough and academically sound process. This structured approach ensures the proposed solution is grounded in real-world data and community needs.
From a technical information perspective, the proposal for a superstructural system with an independent steel frame is an ingenious solution for vertical expansion, minimizing intervention on existing buildings. The integration of prefabricated modular elements (Cross-Laminated Timber - CLT units) alongside steel is highly effective, offering benefits like rapid assembly, reduced carbon emissions, and excellent thermal performance. The emphasis on flexible residential units (single, double, duplexes) that support multi-generational living and adaptation over time is a critical aspect for long-term value. Furthermore, the inclusion of sustainable features like urban farming, vertical gardens, therapeutic spaces, solar panels, and smart water management systems on the readapted roof, along with new service cores, reinforces the project's holistic commitment to sustainability and enhanced quality of life.
To further strengthen this already robust and innovative project, consider these aspects:
Detailed Structural Integration with Existing Buildings: While you mention minimizing intervention, elaborate on the specific connection details and load transfer mechanisms between the new steel superstructure and the diverse range of existing residential buildings. How does this system account for varying structural conditions, ages, and materials of the base buildings in Prishtina's context?
Socio-Economic Feasibility and Affordability: The project aims to address housing shortages and improve quality of life. Consider discussing the socio-economic implications of this vertical expansion. How can the proposed modular, prefabricated units be made affordable and accessible to the existing residents or new populations, ensuring the "symbiotic" approach benefits all demographics and avoids gentrification?
Visual Impact and Urban Integration beyond Function: While the technical and functional aspects are strong, explore in more detail the aesthetic and visual impact of these vertical additions on the existing urban skyline and streetscape of Bregu i Diellit. How does the architectural expression of the new CLT and steel elements harmonize or intentionally contrast with the existing fabric, contributing positively to the neighborhood's evolving identity?
Dear Omar Harb,
Thank you so much for the detailed and insightful feedback on Vertical Fusion: Symbiotic Strategies for Expanding Cities. I truly appreciate the time and depth with which you engaged with the project, and I’m grateful for your valuable suggestions that will help further refine and strengthen the proposal.
Your points about the structural integration, socio-economic feasibility, and urban-visual impact are especially important, and I fully agree that addressing these dimensions in greater detail will enhance both the academic rigor and practical relevance of the project.
Regarding the structural integration, the proposed solution was conceived as a superstructural system that can exist independently with its reinforcement, minimizing intervention in existing buildings. This approach allows the structure to adapt to varying base conditions while providing stability. That is why, at the conclusion of the concept, I proposed that the superstructure could take four typologies (Freestanding building, Complex Fragmented Building, Block Residential Building, and Residential Towers), allowing flexibility in its application. The use of modular square and rectangular units makes it easily adaptable to different buildings and urban contexts, supporting the project’s replicability and scalability.
In terms of socio-economic feasibility, the symbiotic concept focuses strongly on the inclusion of existing communities and in the incorporation of modular components designed for responsible production and easy assembly, aiming for economic affordability and efficiency. Firstly, the design aims to provide opportunities for multi-generational families to remain in the same neighborhood as their life cycles evolve, reducing the need to relocate to other parts of the city. This is particularly relevant for Kosovo, where the average household size is 4.9 members and the typical living space is 67m². The proposed structure offers the potential to align these figures more closely with European standards while promoting social stability and cohesion. Secondly, the choice of steel and natural wood reflects the goal of a lightweight structural system, with wood providing not only a warm, homely feel but also tapping into Kosovo’s potential for utilizing local wood reserves or creating dedicated plantations to support such sustainable developments.
Regarding visual and urban integration, while the new additions may contrast somewhat in form and materials, the overarching aim is to achieve symbiosis between the existing and the new, both architecturally and socially. The integration of key urban principles—such as inclusivity, community values, and human-scale design—helps ensure a positive contribution to the city’s fabric. Of course, I fully agree that a more detailed exploration of visual impact through realistic renderings will be an important part of further development.
Once again, I am grateful for your thoughtful comments. They are truly valued and will help guide the next stages of the project in the future.
Best regards,
Fiona