Reza Keshavarznorozpour

advisor

Islamic Azad University Science and Research Branch

Iranian

Modern architecture projects in a historic urban environment  more

Concept and Idea Development:
The concept of using the leaf as an inspiration is innovative and well-integrated into the project narrative. The leaf metaphor is effectively translated into a flexible and organic form that enhances the urban context. Your focus on connecting the building with its surroundings through ramps and park integration is a commendable strategy to promote accessibility, movement, and continuity in the public space.

Urban and Contextual Integration:
Your analysis of the urban situation is thorough. Positioning the project to address the lack of green spaces in a central urban area reflects a strong understanding of contemporary urban needs. The concept of layering functions (parking below, park above) maximizes land use efficiency and is a sustainable urban strategy, aligning with modern approaches to urban densification and green infrastructure.

Functionality and User Interaction:
The spatial organization considering activities for different age groups and classifying them based on noise levels demonstrates thoughtful user-centered design. This functional zoning enhances the inclusivity and usability of the park for diverse social groups. The design promotes social interaction, recreation, and culture — key elements for a vibrant public space.

Environmental and Technical Aspects:
The integration of natural light and ventilation into the underground parking is a strong sustainable feature, reducing energy demands and enhancing user comfort. Your balanced use of green spaces, water elements, and material choices according to climate and local characteristics shows an understanding of ecological design principles.

Representation and Visualization:
The panel layout is clear and systematically organized, guiding the viewer from concept to technical details and visualizations. Sections and elevations are accurately drawn and express the interaction between the different levels effectively. The 3D visualizations convincingly communicate the intended atmosphere and user experience of the designed space.

Areas for Improvement:

Materiality Details: More specific information about the materials (types, environmental impact, local sourcing) could strengthen the project's sustainability narrative.

Structural Considerations: Given the extensive use of ramps and green roof elements, more emphasis could be placed on structural solutions and waterproofing strategies, to ensure the long-term durability of the park and underground spaces.

Accessibility: While the ramps promote general accessibility, consider adding more explicit elements for universal design (e.g., tactile paving, handrails, resting points for people with limited mobility).

Climate Adaptation: You could further explore the use of native vegetation and water management strategies (like rain gardens or permeable pavements) to enhance resilience to local climatic conditions.

Conclusion:
This project presents a conceptually strong and technically thoughtful solution to urban public space design. It successfully combines aesthetic inspiration, user needs, and environmental considerations. With minor enhancements in technical detailing and material specification, this proposal could become a highly impactful urban intervention.

Dear Reza Keshavarznorozpour, Thank you very much for your valuable feedback. I truly appreciate your guidance, it was extremely helpful!