Patrycja Ziemienowicz
student
AAU - Aalborg University, Denmark
Denmark
Architecture
CONTEXT Proposed is a retreat for a writer who wants to work remote from society and close to nature for some weeks or a few months in order to contemplate and… more
Reza Keshavarznorozpour
advisor
Islamic Azad University Science and Research Branch
Iranian
Modern architecture projects in a historic urban environment more
Scientific and Critical Review
1. Architectural Concept and Form
The Black Monolith’s conceptual grounding is paradox: it appears heavy and impenetrable from a distance yet reveals a light, bright interior upon closer engagement. This duality leverages phenomenology in architecture, manipulating user expectations and emotional responses to built form — an idea rooted in the theories of Christian Norberg-Schulz and Juhani Pallasmaa.
Design Reflection: Examine how architectural phenomenology is implemented through spatial progression, materiality, and visual permeability.
Critical Note: Could a more organic exterior have reinforced a biophilic principle without losing the intended paradoxical character?
2. Materiality and Sustainable Technologies
The exterior uses the ancient Japanese technique Shou Sugi Ban (charred wood) for natural durability, while slate roofing enhances lifespan and resilience. Monocrystalline photovoltaics provide off-grid energy with minimal aesthetic disruption, achieving a seamless integration.
Scientific Basis: Charring wood reduces susceptibility to insects, mold, and UV damage by carbonizing the surface — enhancing lifespan up to 80 years (sources: Journal of Wood Science, 2017).
Critical Question: Could alternative treatments, such as eco-friendly bio-based coatings, offer similar protection with lower embodied energy?
3. Interior and Sensory Stimulation
Internally, the cabin fully embraces biophilic design: untreated hoop pine plywood surfaces promote olfactory stimulation through phytoncides (limonene, pinene), which have been linked in clinical studies to reduced cortisol levels, improved immunity, and lower blood pressure (source: Li, Q., International Journal of Immunopathology and Pharmacology, 2010).
Tactile Design: Contrast between rough exterior and warm, polished interior is not only visual but also tactile, enhancing human connection to material surfaces.
Kinesthetic Integration: The uphill climb to the retreat invites a bodily engagement with landscape, a direct application of kinaesthetic design theories (Richard Sennett, The Craftsman).
4. Energy, Comfort, and Environmental Impact
The retreat's passive and active strategies — optimal orientation, passive solar heating, cross ventilation, chimney effect — support ultra-low energy use of 14.3 kWh/m²/year. Solar panels optimized for winter sun angles maximize autonomy.
Technical Validation: Review the solar optimization using sun path diagrams and energy simulation data (BE18, VELUX Daylight Visualizer).
Off-grid Strategies: Evaluate the limitations and practical challenges of battery storage and water well solutions, especially under extended cloudy winter conditions.
5. Construction and Modularity
The retreat uses modular timber construction, minimizing site disturbance with raised concrete pads. Ventilated rainscreens and rodent protection detailings reveal a thoughtful design against both climatic and biological forces.
Scientific Relevance: Prefabrication reduces carbon footprint by up to 30% compared to traditional construction (source: World Green Building Council 2020 Report).
Comparative Study:
Compare this retreat with another famous biophilic retreat (example: Peter Zumthor’s Bruder Klaus Field Chapel or Olson Kundig’s Delta Shelter).
Critically reflect on differing approaches to sensory immersion and environmental stewardship.