Tamer ElSerafi

advisor

Cairo University, Faculty of Engineering Architecture Department.

Egypt

Dr. Tamer ElSerafi is the Head of the Architecture Department and Director of the Master of Science… more

This project proposes an off-grid sustainable housing model on the outskirts of Karachi, inspired by the traditional Chinese Tulou typology. The use of natural materials—wood, mud bricks, and rammed earth—shows an intention to minimize environmental impact and foster community cohesion through a circular, clustered layout. While the core idea of creating a self-sufficient, resilient settlement is commendable, the project remains underdeveloped in terms of architectural, spatial, and technical resolution.

The conceptual connection to Tulou is introduced but not sufficiently adapted to local climatic, cultural, or urban realities. Spatial organization lacks clarity in relation to functional zoning, hierarchy, circulation, and services. Additionally, the representation—both visual and textual—is minimal and does not convey a comprehensive understanding of how the project would be constructed, inhabited, or sustained over time.

Overall, the proposal reflects a promising conceptual direction but requires significant advancement in architectural detail, contextual adaptation, and the articulation of sustainability systems to meet the expectations of a fully realized design solution.