Alicja Szedel
student
Silesian University of Technology, (Politechnika Śląska), Faculty of Architecture, Gliwice
Poland
Architecture
The Resort of the Silesian University of Technology in Jastrzębia Góra is a project aimed at preventing the demolition of existing structures in favor of new… more
Saeed Amini
advisor
Tehran University of Art
United Arab Emirates
I am an architect, researcher, and architectural critic who views architecture not merely as a… more
This project presents a thoughtful and contextually grounded architectural proposal that demonstrates a mature attitude toward heritage preservation, landscape integration, and contemporary resort design. The decision to retain and adapt the existing university holiday building, rather than replacing it with a new development, is commendable and reflects a responsible and sustainable design approach. The cascading arrangement of the new accommodation units responds convincingly to the site’s significant topographical differences, transforming the 6.2-meter elevation change into a spatial and experiential asset that enhances privacy, views, and the overall character of the complex. The architectural language successfully draws from traditional Pomeranian forms—particularly gable roofs, wooden façade articulation, and regional proportions—while avoiding literal imitation, instead offering a restrained contemporary reinterpretation. The urban strategy is clear and legible, with minimal interference in the natural terrain and a well-balanced relationship between built form, circulation, and open spaces. The project is technically well resolved, with a coherent structural and construction logic that supports the architectural intent. Overall, this is a sensitive and well-crafted proposal that balances respect for local identity with modern functional requirements, resulting in a resort complex that feels integrated, calm, and rooted in its landscape and cultural context.
While the project demonstrates a strong respect for regional architecture, the balance between tradition and contemporary expression could be further refined by introducing clearer contrasts in selected elements such as entrances, shared terraces, or circulation nodes to strengthen the identity of communal spaces within the complex. The cascading layout responds well to the terrain, but the pedestrian movement between levels would benefit from a more articulated sequence of paths, resting points, and viewpoints to enhance orientation and comfort, particularly in winter conditions. Greater differentiation between private accommodation zones and shared resort facilities could improve functional clarity and guest experience. Although the construction system is well defined, the project would gain depth by more explicitly addressing environmental performance, including daylight optimization, natural ventilation, and seasonal thermal comfort, especially in relation to the steep topography. Finally, the presentation could be strengthened by illustrating everyday use scenarios showing how guests occupy outdoor spaces throughout the year to reinforce the project’s social and experiential qualities.
20.12.2025