Omar Harb

advisor

USEK - Holy spirit University of Kaslik

Lebanon

As an architect and founder of Omar Harb Architects & Associates, my work centers on creating… more

Project Evaluation
The project, as described, is a conceptually strong and technically ambitious architectural design. Its strengths lie in its clear vision, innovative use of a central design language, and a focus on both aesthetic and functional integration.

Strengths:

Strong Conceptual Framework: The use of triangular geometry as a functional and aesthetic "language" is a compelling and unified design principle. This approach demonstrates a clear understanding of how form can follow and express function, from softening a theater space to concealing utilities.

Integration of Form and Function: The project description successfully links the exterior facade's visual transformation to the interior's dynamic spatial experience. The idea of the facade's reflectivity responding to the sun and the interior's ramps guiding movement shows a holistic approach to design.

Innovative Use of Circulation: The diagonal ramps in the central atrium are a powerful feature. They not only solve a practical circulation problem but also turn what is often a mundane experience (walking from one floor to another) into a deliberate and dynamic architectural journey. This is a key differentiator for a high-end commercial hotel.

Response to Site and Program: The project's location in a new industrial park adjacent to transportation hubs is a strategic choice. The design's mixed-use program (hotel, conference, dining, etc.) is a direct response to this context, aiming to create a new commercial landmark.

To elevate this project from a strong concept to a fully realized and impactful design, several areas could be further developed and clarified. These suggestions are aimed at strengthening the project's narrative, technical details, and overall impact.

1. Deepen the Narrative of the "Triangular Language"

Suggestion: While the description states that triangular forms "reflect various functional characters," this could be shown more explicitly.

Improvement: Provide a more detailed "case study" within the project. For example, show a plan or section where a specific functional need (like acoustics in the theater) is directly and demonstrably solved by the triangular geometry. This would turn a good idea into a convincing, evidence-based design solution. You could explain how the triangular geometry is used to create acoustic panels, diffusers, or a specific visual effect that enhances the user experience in a particular space.

2. Clarify the Relationship between the Reflective Facade and Interior Experience

Suggestion: The facade is described as reflecting "different colors depending on the angle of the sun."

Improvement: Elaborate on how this visual dynamism of the exterior facade is linked to or perceived from the interior. Does the reflected light create a certain ambiance inside the building? Does it interact with the diagonal ramps to create a specific kind of light show? This would strengthen the project's core idea of "integrating spatial perception and architectural facade." A diagram or rendering showing the light from the facade entering the central atrium at different times of the day would be highly effective.

3. Provide More Context for the "Twisted and Interlocking Blocks"

Suggestion: The design uses twisting and interlocking blocks to create spatial relationships.

Improvement: Explain the reasoning behind this specific volumetric composition. Is it a response to the site's orientation, the need for varied views, or a way to organize the different functions (e.g., conference block, hotel block)? A diagram illustrating how the blocks are organized and how their "twisting" creates specific courtyards or views would make the design logic much clearer.

4. Enhance the Technical and Sustainability Narrative

Suggestion: The project lists a green coverage ratio of 35% but offers no details on how it is achieved.

Improvement: Connect the design's unique features to its sustainability goals. For example, are the triangular forms on the facade part of a brise-soleil (sun-shading) system? Does the reflective facade help with thermal performance? Are the courtyards and green spaces integrated with a rainwater collection system or part of a strategy to improve microclimates? Explicitly linking the project's form to its environmental performance would significantly strengthen its technical and social narrative.

5. Add a "User Experience" Component

Suggestion: The description focuses on the architect's design intent.

Improvement: Imagine the project from the perspective of a user. What is the emotional or functional journey of a guest? For example, "A guest arriving from the transportation hub is immediately drawn into the dynamic atrium by the ramps, which offer a sense of discovery and a clear path to their destination, whether it's the conference center or the hotel lobby." This human-centered perspective would make the project more relatable and its purpose more compelling.