Katinka Földesi, Simon Boróka, Leitner Dalma
student
Budapest University of Technology and Economics
Hungary
Architecture
The housing estate for people with physical disabilities in Pesthidegkút was exemplary in its kind when it was built in the early 1980s. Designed by Tamás… more
Omar Harb
advisor
Phoenicia University
Lebanon
As an architect and founder of Omar Harb Architects & Associates, my work centers on creating… more
Feedback: Pesthidegkút Housing Estate Redevelopment
This project tackles a highly relevant and complex challenge: revitalizing a historically significant housing estate while respecting its unique character and evolving resident needs. Your team's sensitivity to the existing architectural language and community dynamics is commendable.
Overall Concept and Vision
The project idea is exceptionally strong, directly addressing the tension between the preserved identity of the Pesthidegkút housing estate and the contemporary needs of its aging buildings and changing residents. By focusing on architectural interventions that introduce community spaces and services as "contemporary additions to this 'village'," you've framed a solution that respects the past while building for the future. The initial recognition of the estate's exemplary nature and later challenges (e.g., disrupted aesthetics, modernizations, ad-hoc additions) demonstrates a deep analytical understanding of the site's evolution.
Project Description
The design process is logically structured, starting with a problem identification phase that acknowledges the conflict between unified identity and individual adaptations. Your aim to develop a single architectural intervention as an expansion of the existing grocery store is a smart strategic move, leveraging an existing community node and providing an opportunity for façade rehabilitation.
The careful attention paid to the site's authentic architectural character and distinctive textures while still forming an independent architectural unit is a delicate balance effectively addressed. The multi-functional programmatic approach for the central building – including a swimming pool for leisure, a covered market space for local producers, and coffee tables – is well-conceived. This mix not only serves as a community catalyst but also aims to generate external income for maintenance, demonstrating a practical approach to long-term viability. The inclusion of supporting functions (restrooms, changing rooms, reception, storage, bike rack) ensures comprehensive service.
Technical Information
The technical information demonstrates a thoughtful application of materials and structural logic:
Garage Buildings: The approach to address the smallest-scale components first, and the use of the characteristic brick and dark brown I-beams for the garages, directly draws from the estate's existing material palette, ensuring continuity. The design of perforated brick walls with rotated bricks for vertical bracing is an intelligent detail that adds visual interest while maintaining connection to the surroundings. The reinforced concrete slabs with a 5% slope are practical.
Main Building: The choice of green roofs is an excellent sustainable feature, contributing to both environmental benefits and aesthetic integration. Incorporating recesses into the roof surface for natural lighting is a clever design solution.
Market Area: Breaking through the ceiling slab to create a cloister-like space with increased light entry and enhanced spatial experience is an appealing design gesture, encouraging movement and interaction.
To further enhance this already compelling project, consider these aspects:
Detailed Community Engagement and Phasing: While you mention the existing community is aware of issues, elaborate on how residents were or would be directly involved in the design process to ensure the new interventions truly meet their evolving needs and foster long-term ownership. Additionally, given the scale, discuss a potential phasing strategy for implementation, especially for the larger central building, and how this would manage disruption for residents.
Addressing Accessibility Beyond Function: The original estate was exemplary for people with physical disabilities. How do your proposed interventions, particularly the new central building and redesigned outdoor spaces, specifically enhance and extend barrier-free access beyond typical requirements, truly reflecting the estate's founding spirit for people with disabilities? Are there specific design details or features that cater to this group?
Water Management and Microclimate Integration: While green roofs are mentioned, explore more specific strategies for water retention and management related to the swimming pool and market area. For instance, is there a plan for rainwater harvesting and reuse for irrigation or within the pool system? How do the proposed green spaces and new structures contribute to microclimate amelioration (e.g., reducing heat island effect, providing comfortable outdoor spaces) given the local climate?