Omar Harb

advisor

Phoenicia University

Lebanon

As an architect and founder of Omar Harb Architects & Associates, my work centers on creating… more

Overall Concept and Vision
Your project idea is exceptionally well-aligned with the spirit of the Camino de Santiago. The emphasis on mental rest, self-development, and reconnecting with nature, free from modern luxuries, perfectly captures the essence of a pilgrimage. The intention to blend the structure respectfully into the forest with minimal terrain impact is also highly commendable and demonstrates a strong environmental consciousness.

Project Description
The project description clearly articulates the functional layout and user experience. Separating the sleeping units from the communal area is a smart design choice, effectively balancing the need for social interaction with the desire for privacy and quiet rest. The orientation of the units to offer views of the forest and Vrané reservoir sounds beautiful and enhances the connection to nature.

A particularly strong point is the focus on sustainable water management through the use of drinking water supply and recycled rainwater for showering and flushing. This aligns perfectly with the minimalist and environmentally conscious ethos of the project.

Technical Information
The technical information provided demonstrates a robust and well-considered approach to construction. The use of a steel I-beam frame ensures structural integrity, while the layering of OSB boards, mineral insulation, and KVH structural timber points to a high level of thermal and acoustic performance.

The inclusion of a breathable membrane and thermal breaks between steel and wood components highlights attention to detail regarding moisture management and energy efficiency, which are crucial for a long-lasting and comfortable structure.

The choice of Alpine wooden shingles for external cladding is excellent, reinforcing the natural aesthetic and traditional appeal, making the shelter truly blend with its surroundings. The epoxy layer for the interior surface suggests durability and ease of maintenance, which are practical considerations for a high-traffic shelter. Finally, the window recess integration is a good detail, showing a holistic approach to design and insulation.

Suggestions for Further Consideration (Optional)
While the project is strong as is, here are a few minor points that could be considered for even greater depth:

Accessibility: How are the elevated units accessed? Are there ramps or stairs, and how does this impact accessibility for all pilgrims, especially those with mobility challenges?
Waste Management: Beyond water recycling, is there a plan for other waste generated by pilgrims (e.g., composting toilets, refuse disposal)?
Maintenance: Given the remote forest setting and natural materials, what are the long-term maintenance considerations for the wooden shingles and other components?
Overall, this is an excellent project concept with a strong understanding of both the user's needs and the environmental context. You've clearly put a lot of thought into both the aesthetic and functional aspects of the design.

Enhanced Accessibility Considerations
While the elevated design offers beautiful views, consider a detailed plan for universal accessibility. This includes not only ramps or lifts for those with mobility challenges, but also features within the units themselves, like wider doorways or grab bars, to ensure all pilgrims can comfortably and safely use the shelter. Think about the entire journey from ground level to bed.

Holistic Waste Management Strategy
You've smartly incorporated rainwater recycling; now, expand on your sustainable approach to include a comprehensive waste management strategy. This could involve composting toilets to minimize water usage and process organic waste on-site, a system for managing greywater from showers (beyond just flushing), and dedicated, clearly labeled bins for different types of recyclable materials. The goal is a truly minimal environmental footprint.

Long-Term Material Resilience and Maintenance
Given the forest setting and natural materials like Alpine wooden shingles, develop a proactive maintenance plan for the shelter's longevity. This should detail how these materials will withstand weather variations, potential pest issues, and general wear and tear over time. For example, specify treatment schedules for the wood, or consider how easily individual shingles can be replaced to ensure the shelter remains both aesthetically pleasing and structurally sound for many years to come.