PROJECTS FEEDBACK
Any participant in the INSPIRELI AWARDS competition can ask a member of the international jury for feedback on his/her competition project. Jurors are assigned across continents at a ratio of one juror per student. The resulting gallery is a unique architecture textbook, created free of charge by those who wish to participate in our project and contribute their work to the education of the up and coming generation. We are honored that you are sharing your designs and experiences here.
504 Results
Memorial projects feedbacks
This is a very touching project. It is extremely difficult to combine the tragic past and the cloudless present into an organic whole. The past is still invisibly present and clouds memories. And only sinless rabbits can probably neutralize the painful impression of this place. The project is attractive for its spontaneity, openness and directness. Perhaps it is utopian and will never be realized. But it must be voiced, it must be heard. Because it in itself is a call for world peace, for unity…
Eugenia Vdovina
advisor
The project is very organic and poetic, showing the breadth of the author’s horizons, the ability to organically integrate not only architecture into the landscape, but also previously implemented technical innovations into a new context. The scale of the plan and at the same time its rationality and relevance are pleasantly surprising. The idea of synthesizing natural and artificial waterfalls deserves special attention. It promotes the unity of internal and external spaces. The wording…
Eugenia Vdovina
advisor
The project is dashing and pretentious. Visually it is very organic and aesthetic. The bold play with volumes and levels is captivating. The presentation of the project corresponds to its essence - concise and balanced. As a primary image, this project is quite viable. Personally, I don’t have enough design documentation to understand the architectural and technological specifics. And the conceptual justification lacks sincerity and personal interest. The project is cold and universal. Such…
Eugenia Vdovina
advisor
The project is beautiful in its incompleteness and mystery, it makes you think. This is also facilitated by the excellent visualization concept. It is both visual and atmospheric. The idea of the ongoing revolution of the past, their continuous work on the minds of descendants, is very promising. However, the thesis about the presence of instructions for the correct “use” of the territory by the viewer is not fully disclosed. In what format are these instructions presented to you? Will it be a…
Eugenia Vdovina
advisor
The project is very well presented, demonstrating strong skills in postproduction and renderings. The student shows a keen awareness of the natural landscape, and the incorporation of a green corridor into the master plan is a key aspect of the design. Sustainability practices have been introduced in detail, showcasing the student’s understanding of how various systems work together. The site analysis is also clear, emphasizing the project’s proximity to the rail and adjacent roads, which…
Samer Samarani
advisor
While drawing inspiration from fluid shapes that represent natural elements is an excellent conceptual starting point, the project should be more site-specific. It’s essential for the design to reflect the unique elements and surroundings of the site. By grounding the project in its location, the design will not only honor the natural environment but also create a more meaningful relationship between the architecture and its context. When parametric design is introduced, establishing clear…
Samer Samarani
advisor
I am very glad to see that the classification of senses and the activity area can be clearly analyzed and combined, which is undoubtedly a very beneficial thing for the visually impaired. The sensory understanding shown in the picture is also in place, as well as a reasonable understanding of relevant laws and regulations. What I want to say is that as a project with very practical needs, We may need to pay more attention to the understanding of some small scenes. For example, some scenes…
QingYang Jia
advisor
The starting point of the project is uplifting, to commemorate the nameless victims, and I think there is nothing wrong with the design process of the monument, but the expression could perhaps be a little more emotional, especially as an emotional structure, the notebook style may not be able to convey the emotional connection of war, reflection, grief in the first place. The treatment of the landscape is very good, but as an overall design you have to consider its response to the monument. I…
QingYang Jia
advisor
There is little sense of intrusion into the building, and it is better to have frames for intrusion. The legibility of the plan is low
Amir Kolivand
advisor
Copyright © 2024 INSPIRELI | All rights reserved. Use of this website signifies your agreement to the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy, and use of cookies.
