PROJECTS FEEDBACK
Any participant in the INSPIRELI AWARDS competition can ask a member of the international jury for feedback on his/her competition project. Jurors are assigned across continents at a ratio of one juror per student. The resulting gallery is a unique architecture textbook, created free of charge by those who wish to participate in our project and contribute their work to the education of the up and coming generation. We are honored that you are sharing your designs and experiences here.
202 Results
Farm projects feedbacks
There is little sense of intrusion into the building, and it is better to have frames for intrusion.
Amir Kolivand
advisor
It is an interesting project and I like the way you have strategically created eight zones for the site but somehow I feel that the critical potentials of this project were undermined. I agree that the lake is nearly 350 sq.km of area and offers a blend of diversified ecology; however, critical aspects were missed and the solutions failed to provide judicious evaluation. If you had studied key limnological variables you would have realised that water transparency is zero and the amount of…
Himanshu Sanghani
advisor
I really appreciate the concept and the starting point of this project, and how the ideas are translated into space, materials and experience. Great design and great details, with intriguing interior renderings, I found this as a very successful practice.
Ziyang Xu
advisor
PROJECT: REDEVELOPMENT OF SYLHET OLD CENTRAL JAIL AREA (An opportunity to create an urban activity area for Sylhet city) STUDENT: RIDAY SAHA INSTITUTION: Bangladesh University, Department of Architecture, Dhaka COUNTRY: Bangladesh SEMIFINAL JUROR: Wandile Sibandze 1. STRENGTHS: Interpreting the memory of a place in terms of heritage architecture and the importance of its preservation (specific understanding of the unique environment) convincingly. The subject matter is well understood and…
Wandile Sibandze
advisor
In my opinion, this project remains an interesting concept that, following an exhaustive study, could become an inspiring model for similar initiatives on a global scale. However, I am skeptical about the risks associated with public safety, particularly regarding public access during the construction phase, which could pose significant safety concerns. Even with precautions in place, there is a considerable risk that the process of dismantling and dune creation could disrupt the surrounding…
Josefina MONTE-NGUBA SIALE
advisor
The showroom design for Iris Van Herpen harmoniously combines innovation, creativity and functionality. The Iris Van Herpen clothes presented there gain a new setting that highlights their uniqueness and artistic value. Right from the entrance, thanks to the reception desk inspired by the designer's work, visitors are introduced to the world of unusual forms and modern technologies. The welcome area, bar and rest areas ensure comfort for guests, and the thoughtful arrangement of dresses in the…
Dominika Zawojska-Kuriata
advisor
The first impression is there are many line elements (vertically and horizontally), and the lettering of the building name needs to be more balanced (just simple and not that much) The statement "Business incubator to improve the city's local economy" must accompany more open space for the local community. Openness can be linked to landscape organizations so that it doesn't seem self-limiting (exclusive). The ordering principle and roof completion in the top-view site plan are well done.…
Mustika WARDHANI
advisor
PROJECT: THE AWAKENING OF THE BLACK CANAL STUDENT: Khanh Duy Vo Nguyen, Truong Tran Long, Minh Thien Nguyen Duong, Nguyen Khang Le Van, Khanh Duy Le Nguyen INSTITUTION: University of Architecture Ho Chi Minh City COUNTRY: Viet Nam SEMIFINAL JUROR: Wandile Sibandze 1. STRENGTHS: It is a beautiful and professionally prepared document. It is clear that the subject matter is well understood and researched by the candidate and that it is close to his ‘heart’ and sensibilities. The candidate…
Wandile Sibandze
advisor
Your project for the Agricultural Research Center in Qena incorporates several key components that collectively aim to advance organic agriculture and engage the community. The inclusion of specialized research facilities, interactive food experiences, and educational exhibitions demonstrates a holistic approach to promoting sustainable farming practices. Your project has the potential to be a pioneering model for organic farming in Egypt, setting a standard for sustainability and…
Shanu Agarwal
advisor
Copyright © 2024 INSPIRELI | All rights reserved. Use of this website signifies your agreement to the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy, and use of cookies.
