Sakib Nasir Khan, Adiba Farheen Mrinmoyee, Taufiq Elahi, Kamrul Hasan Sajid
student
Bangladesh University of Engineering & Technology, Department of Architecture, Faculty of Architecture and Planning, Dhaka
Bangladesh
Urban Design and Landscape
Kalshi Canal is a man-made waterway located in the northern part of Dhaka metropolitan city, Bangladesh. It is a relatively small canal that runs through the… more
Tamer ElSerafi
advisor
Cairo University, Faculty of Engineering Architecture Department.
Egypt
Dr. Tamer ElSerafi is the Head of the Architecture Department and Director of the Master of Science… more
This project identifies a real and urgent environmental and public health issue—the degradation of the Kalshi Canal in northern Dhaka—and commendably attempts to address it through urban and landscape design interventions. The proposal suggests a series of low-tech ecological strategies including riparian buffers, community gardens, staged walkways, green roofs, and wastewater filtration systems. These strategies, though conceptually valid, remain underdeveloped both spatially and technically.
While the project articulates several environmental and social goals, it lacks coherence in terms of architectural expression, spatial organization, and implementation feasibility. The visual materials do not clearly communicate design resolution, and the scale of intervention across various sites appears inconsistent and fragmentary. There is limited integration between social engagement strategies and the proposed physical interventions, and the handling of informal settlements is insufficiently explored beyond observational notes.
Overall, the proposal shows good intent and site understanding, but its design maturity, spatial clarity, and execution strategy are inadequate to realize its stated ambitions. A more robust and phased masterplan with defined pilot interventions, stakeholder engagement, and clearer metrics for success would substantially improve its credibility and impact.
Dear Tamer ElSerafi,
Thank you for your detailed feedback. I will try to develop it further based on the suggestions you made.
Sincerely,S
Sakib