Sakib Khan
student
Bangladesh University of Engineering & Technology, Department of Architecture, Faculty of Architecture and Planning, Dhaka
Bangladesh
Architecture
Most developing countries in Asia are going through a rapid urbanisation, and few cities illustrate the tension between dense population and strained… more
Yixuan Liu
advisor
University of California, Berkeley
United States of America
Yixuan Liu has led multiple high-profile architectural projects from concept through construction,… more
This project is very detailed and thoughtful. From site analysis and population distribution to spatial configuration and material choices, every aspect has been carefully considered in a way that feels both practical and actionable. The design is highly implementable, not just a conceptual exercise. What is particularly clever about this project is how it draws inspiration from Old Dhaka’s traditional spatial language - Angina (small private courtyard for women), Uthan/Rowak (front yard or porch), Gali (narrow alley), and Morh (corner node), and integrates these concepts into a modern transitional shelter. This allows the temporary settlements to feel familiar and culturally grounded, while simultaneously organizing space in a way that naturally supports privacy, social interaction, and community cohesion. It’s a subtle but brilliant way to weave local heritage into a post-disaster solution.
The modular shelter units, semi-private courtyards, narrow alleyways, shared kitchens, and sanitation facilities are all designed not only to meet the immediate physical needs of disaster survivors, but also to support social interaction and community life. At the same time, the design is sensitive to the historical and cultural context of Old Dhaka, which demonstrates the designer’s ability to combine technical rigor with humanistic insight.
From a critical perspective, there are areas where the project could be strengthened. In terms of functionality and spatial strategy, the modular layout and material choices, while clever, could face real-world challenges in a post-disaster setting. Construction safety, structural durability, and the community’s ability to self-organize are potential risks. The size and number of shelter units may not fully accommodate larger populations, and the semi-private courtyards and alleyways, while socially rich, could present privacy and safety issues in a high-density urban environment.
Overall, it’s evident that the designer has a strong humanitarian spirit. The project brilliantly embodies the temporary nature of refugee settlements while providing disaster survivors with essential material and spatial support. To take it even further and maximize social impact, the design could more explicitly address post-disaster psychological recovery.
A few advices on how to implement the psychological recovery process into the design:
For example, the shelters could evolve through stages, from skeletal framework to temporary units, then a two-year transitional structure, and finally dismantling, which mirrors the psychological progression of survivors. The other possible approach would be to intergrate Maslow’s hierarchy of needs, covering physiological, safety, social, esteem, and self-actualization requirements. This could help the spatial and functional layout support both survival and emotional rehabilitation.
With further attention to psychological recovery, it could become an even more profound model for post-disaster urban resilience.