PROJECTS FEEDBACK
Any participant in the INSPIRELI AWARDS competition can ask a member of the international jury for feedback on his/her competition project. Jurors are assigned across continents at a ratio of one juror per student. The resulting gallery is a unique architecture textbook, created free of charge by those who wish to participate in our project and contribute their work to the education of the up and coming generation. We are honored that you are sharing your designs and experiences here.
360 Results
Multi Unit Housing projects feedbacks
This is a very touching project. It is extremely difficult to combine the tragic past and the cloudless present into an organic whole. The past is still invisibly present and clouds memories. And only sinless rabbits can probably neutralize the painful impression of this place. The project is attractive for its spontaneity, openness and directness. Perhaps it is utopian and will never be realized. But it must be voiced, it must be heard. Because it in itself is a call for world peace, for unity…
Eugenia Vdovina
advisor
The project is very well presented, demonstrating strong skills in postproduction and renderings. The student shows a keen awareness of the natural landscape, and the incorporation of a green corridor into the master plan is a key aspect of the design. Sustainability practices have been introduced in detail, showcasing the student’s understanding of how various systems work together. The site analysis is also clear, emphasizing the project’s proximity to the rail and adjacent roads, which…
Samer Samarani
advisor
The integration of the three building blocks is well-executed. Utilizing the site’s slope to create terraces is a smart approach, and the use of timber adds to the sustainability aspect of the design. However, the three blocks should be connected internally at some point, unless the intent is for them to function independently. Connecting them would enhance the overall cohesion of the project. The floor plan and detailed façade show intelligent design, allowing for flexibility and adaptability,…
Samer Samarani
advisor
Among several projects under - Schindler's Ark Saving Competition - that I reviewed I think your project closely follows the theme and overall context of the region. I like your process diagram and how you intend to maintain the overall look and appeal but the project could have been even more interesting if you had incorporated the actualities more strongly. History informs us that the place was used as a factory first for textile and later for enamelware; I strongly believe that traits of…
Himanshu Sanghani
advisor
Very interesting structure concept and system, the typical unit layout is helping with telling the story as well, it will be great to see more opportunity in facade design and interior
Ziyang Xu
advisor
Dear Ahmed Sameh and Mai Diab You have done a very good job in designing urban housing entitled "WAVES Compound". It is really aesthetical pleasing functional and implementable. Though I have very few comments for improvement. 1. In you design you have done a very good job for coming up with 32 buildings that have variety in terms of building typology (5) and considered 4 income levels. The gap is that you should have also included variety of Architectural plans in terms of bedroom number…
FIKRESELAM GEBREWAHED FISSEHA
advisor
Dear Малика Абаева Your project on design of "Residential complex "CIRCLE" in Bishkek" looks really good. my minor comments for improvement are stated as follows 1. You should improve your plan presentation skill because the shadow effect on your typical plan is not clear to understand because of the unnecessary shadow effect. Hence, it is very difficult to give detailed comments on the plan. Moreover, you have mentioned that the plan is typical however it is not clear on which floors…
FIKRESELAM GEBREWAHED FISSEHA
advisor
'Entering' the panel presentation scene by scene made me feel like I was being insinuated that architecture should not be different from what grows in nature. This is a great concept, starting from the solar radiation on-site context and the issue of urban heat in Taipei. You and the team bring back the touch of a developing city regarding 'ecology'. Process diagrams are fascinating in the macro realm, such as seeing plants being sown. The tower's geometry is also not arbitrary in its decision…
Mustika WARDHANI
advisor
Attention to the issue of interiority through a gender perspective is an issue in 'patriarchal' countries. This creates an opportunity to provide 'mental space' for women to achieve self-actualization to the level of emancipation. The presentation of a complete synthesis starting from the site context is complemented by sketches that convey a sense of originality and bubble diagrams that clarify the design process. Designing circulation, shape, and mass is still in the 'comfort zone.' The…
Mustika WARDHANI
advisor
Copyright © 2024 INSPIRELI | All rights reserved. Use of this website signifies your agreement to the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy, and use of cookies.
