Nazifa Nawar Subha
student
Bangladesh University of Engineering & Technology, Department of Architecture, Faculty of Architecture and Planning, Dhaka
Bangladesh
Architecture
Informal settlements cling to Dhaka's unjustly excluded urban fabric, sprawling incessantly across the city-without an intention. Eco-Homes, in a bid to stitch… more
Omar Harb
advisor
Phoenicia University
Lebanon
As an architect and founder of Omar Harb Architects & Associates, my work centers on creating… more
Feedback: Eco-Homes: Enhancing the Urban Poor of Sattola, Dhaka
This project presents an incredibly comprehensive, empathetic, and innovative solution to the critical challenges faced by urban informal settlements in Dhaka. Nazifa, your work demonstrates a profound understanding of the complex socio-economic, environmental, and architectural dimensions of this issue.
Overall Concept and Vision
The project idea is exceptionally powerful, aiming to "stitch sustainability, dignity, and hope with circular architecture" to reclaim the urban fabric for Dhaka's unjustly excluded urban poor. Your clear identification of the problems (exorbitant rents, lack of amenities, sketchy government projects) and your two core questions (healthy/affordable housing globally, and anti-eviction redevelopment) establish a vital, research-driven foundation. The vision for a "humane, modular, and scalable solution" that preserves cultural identity through repurposed components is a truly holistic and inspiring approach.
Project Description
The three design narratives are brilliant in their clarity and direct address of the problems:
The Incremental Eco-Homes: This narrative offers a practical and empowering solution. The modular, prefabricated system that allows for incremental expansion as residents' incomes grow, coupled with the significant cost reduction through recycled materials, directly tackles affordability and dignity. The agency given to residents to choose and upgrade infill materials fosters ownership and prevents financial burden.
The Anti-Eviction Grid: This is a crucial and often overlooked aspect of slum redevelopment. Your phased redevelopment strategy with the "ANTI-Eviction Grid" system, breaking the site into manageable clusters and providing temporary government-rented shelters, is a humane and highly effective strategy to prevent displacement and the formation of new informal settlements. The 7-8 month completion time per cluster highlights practical efficiency.
Rooted in Tradition: Emphasizing community participation in design and construction is fundamental for fostering ownership and reducing labor costs, directly combating gentrification. The integration of communal kitchens, rooftop vegetable farming, courtyards for social interaction, rainwater harvesting, poultry farming, and an inexpensive greywater treatment system creates a truly self-sufficient and culturally resonant community. The focus on entrepreneurship through construction, maintenance, and small shop modules demonstrates a holistic approach to economic empowerment.
Technical Information
This section provides crucial details that underscore the project's feasibility and ingenuity:
Circular Economy: The use of recycled doors, windows (50% cost reduction), and re-bars from C&D waste is exemplary, directly addressing waste streams and affordability.
Flexible Infill Options: Allowing dwellers to choose cheaper temporary infills (Zincalume, cane mats, repurposed wood) and upgrade later showcases immense flexibility and responsiveness to varying income levels.
Resilient Structure: The mandate for a concrete structure to withstand fire incidents, even if temporary infills burn, is a critical safety consideration for dense settlements.
Modular Construction: The mass-production of beams and columns and their erection with the Gauss plate joinery system highlights efficiency, ease of installation, and facilitation of self-build by residents, enhancing ownership.
Replicability of Temporary Shelters: The idea of reusing temporary shelters across 57 DAP sites demonstrates a strategic, scalable solution for humanitarian housing.
Incremental Expansion: The design clearly supports residents extending their units with pre-existing structural elements, offering adaptable space for storage or balconies.
Mezzanine Layer: The introduction of a mezzanine for guest sleeping or storage in concise dwelling modules is a smart spatial optimization.
To further enhance this already exemplary project, consider these aspects:
Quantifying Social and Economic Impact: While the project clearly aims for social and economic benefits, providing more specific metrics or case studies on how similar strategies have quantitatively improved livelihoods, reduced poverty cycles, or fostered entrepreneurship in comparable contexts would strengthen the argument for its real-world impact.
Addressing Long-Term Maintenance and Management: Beyond residents participating in initial construction, elaborate on the long-term operational model for maintenance of communal facilities, infrastructure (like greywater treatment), and shared spaces. What governance structures or community-led initiatives would ensure the sustained quality and functionality of the "Eco-Homes" over decades?
Microclimate and Thermal Comfort Details: Given Dhaka's climate, while general passive strategies are mentioned, a deeper dive into specific microclimate design elements (e.g., prevailing wind studies to optimize cross-ventilation, specific shading devices, integration of vegetation for evaporative cooling, material thermal mass performance) would further strengthen the sustainable credentials.