Franc Obguia

advisor

Cebu Institute of Technology – University (CIT-U), College of Engineering and Architecture, Cebu City

Philippines

Architecture and Sustainability more

The Schindler's Ark is beautifully structured and thoughtfully executed, with a clear narrative that captures both the history and the contemporary vision for the Schindler's Ark Museum. The flow of information is smooth, and each section is clearly marked, making it easy to follow your ideas and understand the intentions behind the design. The overall presentation board has a great balance of visuals and text, allowing the project to speak for itself while providing enough explanation to clarify your design choices.

The renders are striking and do an excellent job of conveying the fusion between the historic factory and the modern design elements. The play of materials—such as the historic brick and the expansive glass paneling—creates a beautiful contrast that effectively communicates the dialogue between the old and the new. This thoughtful juxtaposition enhances the museum’s ability to honor its historical context while inviting a fresh, contemporary perspective. The integration of natural surroundings with the building design is particularly impressive, as it strengthens the connection between the museum and the land, offering visitors a holistic experience.

Your architectural plans show a keen understanding of how to enrich a historic space while maintaining its integrity. The flow of the building's layout encourages exploration and offers moments of reflection, creating a space that not only educates but also invites visitors to engage with the history in a meaningful way. The use of glass panels ensures ample natural light, and the strategic placement of public and private spaces is well-thought-out, offering visitors both a sense of openness and privacy as they interact with the exhibits.

One suggestion would be to make the vegetation in the renders more realistic, as this would help bring the exterior spaces to life and showcase the relationship between the architecture and nature more vividly. Additionally, adding people to the renders would provide a sense of scale and activity, further enhancing the dynamic atmosphere of the museum.

Thank you, Krištof Tall, for your participation in the Inspireli competition. Your project is an inspiring approach to blending history with modernity, and it’s clear that you've put much thought into creating a space that not only respects the past but also creates a new narrative for visitors. Congratulations on your submission, and I look forward to seeing your future projects!