Emilia Luty, Adrianna Jankowiak
student
Poznań University of Technology (Politechnika Poznańska), Faculty of Architecture, Poznań
Poland
Architecture
The designated area is located on the Poland-Germany border, between the Polish city of Słubice and Frankfurt (Oder). The design proposes to transform the old… more
Saeed Amini
advisor
Tehran University of Art
United Arab Emirates
I am an architect, researcher, and architectural critic who views architecture not merely as a… more
this project is valued for its sensitive response to a highly specific cross-border context and for its clear ambition to transform an underused harbour into a shared civic landscape of integration, leisure, and ecological awareness. The proposal convincingly recognizes the strategic position of the site near the Słubice–Frankfurt (Oder) crossing and translates this into a strong public-oriented program that blends recreation, sport, culture, and nature in a balanced way. The building is carefully embedded into the flood embankment, which demonstrates a thoughtful understanding of the hydrological conditions and results in a harmonious relationship between architecture and landscape. The system of elevated and ground-level piers is particularly successful in activating the wetlands while respecting their ecological value and ensuring accessibility even during fluctuating water levels. The introduction of the water stage further enriches the public character of the site and adds an important cultural layer to the project. Architecturally, the restrained expression of the building, the repetition of structural elements on the façade, and the integration of an openwork canopy and green roof create a coherent identity that remains subordinate to the landscape. Overall, the project presents a well-balanced synthesis of infrastructure, public space, and natural environment, offering a convincing vision for revitalizing the harbour as a meaningful cross-border meeting place.
While the project demonstrates a strong understanding of the site and its flood-related constraints, the functional relationship between the building’s interior program and the surrounding piers could be further clarified to strengthen everyday usability and visitor orientation. The transition between the natural wetland zones and the more intensively used public areas would benefit from a more gradual spatial gradient, allowing for a smoother shift from landscape to architecture. Greater attention could also be given to shading, wind protection, and seasonal comfort along the piers and terraces to support year-round use. Although the integration of the building into the embankment is convincing, the visibility and legibility of the main entrances could be enhanced to improve wayfinding from both land and water. Finally, the long-term maintenance strategy for the green roof, piers, and flood-prone lower level could be more explicitly addressed to ensure durability and sustainable operation over time.
07.12.2025